New York Sour Cocktail Recipe: The Complete Journey to Crafting an Impeccable Drink

New York Sour Cocktail: Easy Recipe & Pro Tips

Discover everything you need to know about the New York Sour cocktail—from preparation and mixing tips to calorie counts and ideal food pairings. Your ultimate guide to mastering this classic drink

New York Sour Cocktail Ingredients

  • Whiskey: 60 ml (2 oz.)
  • Fresh Lemon Juice: 30 ml (1 oz.)
  • Simple Syrup: 15 ml (0.5 oz.)
  • Red Wine Float: 15 ml (0.5 oz.)
  • Ice Cubes: As needed
  • Lemon Slice: For garnish

Savor a New York Sour and taste bourbon’s strong kick, soften by sweet syrupy sugar. The lemon takes the edge off, while a bold red wine float adds a fruity finish. Cheers!

New York Sour Recipe: Step-by-Step Preparation

Preparation Time: 5 Minutes

Step 1: Measure and Pour Whiskey

Start off by pouring 60 ml (2 oz.) of your chosen whiskey into a cocktail shaker. Whether you’ve gone for a premium choice like Redbreast 12 Year Old or a budget-friendly option like Buffalo Trace, measuring accurately ensures the cocktail’s balance.

Step 2: Add Fresh Lemon Juice

Next, squeeze fresh lemon juice until you have 30 ml (1 oz.) and add it to the shaker. Always opt for fresh lemons, as bottled lemon juice lacks the zing and natural oils that contribute to the cocktail’s complexity.

Step 3: Incorporate Simple Syrup

For the sweet element, add 15 ml (0.5 oz.) of simple syrup to your shaker. Simple syrup is easy to make at home; just dissolve equal parts sugar in hot water and let it cool.

Step 4: Ice It Up

Drop a handful of fresh, large ice cubes into your cocktail shaker. The idea here is to chill the drink without diluting it too much, so avoid using crushed or small ice cubes.

Step 5: Shake, Shake, Shake

Firmly place the lid on your shaker and give it a vigorous shake for about 12–15 seconds. You’re not just mixing ingredients; you’re aerating the cocktail for a smoother, frothier texture.

Step 6: Strain into Glass

Take a rock glass and fill it with a large ice sphere or fresh, large ice cubes. Now, using both your cocktail shaker’s built-in strainer and a fine-mesh sieve, double strain the shaken mixture into the glass. This removes any ice shards or unwanted pulp.

Step 7: The Red Wine Float

Now for the pièce de résistance—the red wine float. Pour 15 ml (0.5 oz.) of a full-bodied red wine (like Cabernet Sauvignon) over the back of a spoon, letting it float on top of the existing mixture. This technique allows for that visually stunning two-layer effect.

Step 8: Garnish and Serve

Finally, garnish with a twist of lemon peel. Not only does it add a dash of color, but the lemon oils also contribute an inviting aroma. Your New York Sour is now ready to impress!

h and full-bodied. Its notes of dried fruit, nuts, and a subtle spice complement the tanginess of the lemon and the sweetness of the simple syrup.

How to Spot Authentic Redbreast 12
  • Packaging: Look for a well-designed label with intricate detailing.
  • Color: A rich amber tone is your clue to its authenticity.

Yamazaki 12 Year Old

Taking the New York Sour on a world tour? Yamazaki’s 12-year-old adds a unique Japanese twist. Known for its immaculate balance of fruit and smoke, this single malt will inject an exotic flair. Imagine your lemon’s zing melding seamlessly with its apple and melon notes.

Pairing Yamazaki with Specific Red Wines
  • Cabernet Sauvignon: The wine’s full-bodied nature harmonizes with Yamazaki’s complexity.
  • Merlot: For a softer touch, the wine’s subdued tannins work wonders.

Budget-Friendly Whiskey Brands: Maximum Flavor, Minimum Expense

Buffalo Trace

One of the best bang-for-the-buck options out there, Buffalo Trace offers an impressive array of flavors for its price. This Kentucky straight bourbon is sweet, spicy, and just a little bit complex, making it an excellent choice for a wallet-friendly New York Sour.

Why Buffalo Trace Over Others?
  • Versatility: This whiskey is not only great for cocktails but also stands well on its own.
  • Availability: It’s widely distributed, so you won’t have to search far and wide.

Wild Turkey 101

If you want your New York Sour to pack a punch, Wild Turkey 101 is your go-to option. This high-proof bourbon adds a more robust, spicy kick to the cocktail. Its complex flavors and high alcohol content ensure that it does not overpower the other ingredients.

Pro Tips for Using Wild Turkey 101
  • Adjust the Simple Syrup: Given its potency, you might want to tweak the sweetness level.
  • Use Sparingly: Due to its higher proof, less is often more.

Pro Mixology Tips for Crafting the Perfect New York Sour

The New York Sour isn’t just another whiskey cocktail; it’s an experience waiting to be crafted. Whether you’re a seasoned mixologist or a beginner looking to impress, these pro tips will help you elevate your cocktail game.

The Art of Shaking: Why Technique Matters

Shake Like a Pro

The way you shake your New York Sour is not just for show; it fundamentally alters the drink’s texture. A vigorous shake will aerate the cocktail, making it smoother and frothier. For optimum results, shake for 12–15 seconds.

Tools Matter
  • Cobbler Shaker: Great for beginners, as it’s an all-in-one tool.
  • Boston Shaker: Preferred by pros for its precision and control.

Fine-Straining: Go the Extra Mile

To get rid of unwanted ice shards and pulp, consider double-straining your cocktail. Use a fine-mesh sieve in addition to your shaker’s built-in strainer for a cleaner pour.

Crafting the Ideal Red Wine Float: It’s All in the Pour

Master the Spoon Technique

Pouring the red wine float can be tricky, but it’s crucial for that two-tone visual effect. Gently pour the wine over the back of a spoon, letting it trickle down the inner wall of the glass. This slows down the pour and allows the wine to float atop the cocktail.

Best Spoons for the Job
  • Bar Spoons: Long and thin, ideal for precision.
  • Teaspoons: If you’re in a pinch, a regular teaspoon can work as well.

Choosing the Right Wine

The wine you choose can either clash with or complement your cocktail. Opt for a full-bodied red wine like Cabernet Sauvignon or Zinfandel. These wines have enough character to stand up to the robust flavors of whiskey and citrus.

Ice, Ice, Baby: Don’t Underestimate Its Role

Always Opt for Fresh Ice

The quality of your ice can make or break your New York Sour. Melting old or low-quality ice can dilute the flavors. Use fresh, large ice cubes for shaking and serving.

Ice Shape Guide
  • Cubed ice It is best for shaking, as it chills the cocktail quickly.
  • Sphere Ice: Ideal for serving, as it melts slowly and looks elegant.

Lemon Garnish: The Finishing Touch

Choosing the Perfect Lemon

Go for lemons that are bright yellow and firm to the touch. A heavy lemon usually indicates more juice, which is essential for your New York Sour.

Mastering the Lemon Twist

A twist isn’t just decorative; it also releases essential oils that add a subtle aroma. Use a Y-peeler to get a wide swath of lemon peel, making sure to avoid the bitter white pith.

Elevate Your New York Sour Experience with Ideal Food Pairings

Pairing your New York Sour with the right foods can transform an ordinary evening into a gourmet experience. But what foods go best with this cocktail’s complex layers of whiskey, lemon, and red wine? Let’s dive into a culinary journey perfectly tailored to complement your crafted drink.

Decadent Cheese Choices: An Unbeatable Classic

The Allure of Blue Cheese

The potent, tangy flavors of blue cheese form a remarkable harmony with the New York Sour’s sharp and sweet undertones. Imagine sipping your cocktail and then biting into a chunk of blue cheese—each will elevate the other, creating a whole greater than the sum of its parts.

How to Serve Blue Cheese
  • Wedges: For a rustic approach, serve it in large wedges.
  • Crumbled: Crumble it over a salad with dried fruits to mirror the cocktail’s complexity.

Sharp Cheddar: The Everyman’s Choice

For a more universally accepted option, the boldness of sharp cheddar stands up well to a New York Sour. The cheese’s nutty undertones add an extra layer of depth to your cocktail experience.

Best Cheddar Types for New York Sour
  • Aged Cheddar: Its crumbly texture and strong flavor are a home run.
  • Smoked Cheddar: Introduces an exciting, smoky dynamic to the pairing.

Seafood Wonders: Dive into Sophistication

Grilled Shrimp: Ocean Meets Orchard

Grilled shrimp has a lightness and natural sweetness that complement the New York Sour excellently. It’s like a refreshing sea breeze that cleanses your palate, making each sip of your cocktail feel like the first.

Marinade Ideas
  • Garlic and Lemon: Mimic the cocktail’s citrusy notes.
  • Chili Flakes: To introduce a little heat, making for a more robust experience.

Oysters: For the Bold and the Brave

Oysters have a distinct, briny flavor profile that can be beautifully offset by the New York Sour’s flavor profile. The cocktail’s acidity cuts through the oyster’s richness, while the oyster’s earthy tones ground the sweetness. 

Best Oyster Types for Pairing
  • Pacific Oysters: Known for their sweet, creamy texture.
  • Atlantic Oysters are more robust and briny, offering a contrasting flavor profile.

Vegetarian Alternatives: Light and Flavorful

Stuffed Bell Peppers

Stuffed with grains and veggies, these offer a lighter alternative that still packs a flavor punch. The New York Sour can slice through the dish’s denseness, providing a refreshing counterpoint.

What to Stuff
  • Quinoa and Black Beans: For a protein-rich, nutritious option
  • Rice and Mushrooms: For a more traditional, comforting choice,

New York Sour Unveiled: Your Top FAQs Answered

What Makes the New York Sour Visually Unique?

The New York Sour stands out for its stunning visual appeal, featuring two distinctive layers—a whiskey-lemon mix on the bottom and a vibrant red wine float on top. This gradient effect not only makes the cocktail Instagram-worthy but also adds complexity to the drink, teasing your palate with varying flavors as you sip.

How Many Calories Are in a New York Sour?

On average, a New York Sour contains about 200–220 calories. This estimate includes the whiskey, lemon juice, simple syrup, and red wine float. It’s worth noting that using a sugar substitute for the simple syrup or opting for a lower-calorie wine can alter the caloric content.

Are There Any Allergy Concerns with a New York Sour?

If you have a citrus allergy, the lemon juice in a New York Sour could pose a problem. Additionally, sulfites in red wine can trigger allergies in sensitive individuals. Always check the ingredients and, when in doubt, consult with a healthcare provider before indulging in any cocktail.

What’s the Average Cost of a New York Sour?

The cost of a New York Sour can vary widely depending on the quality of the ingredients used. If you’re making it at home, expect to spend between $2 and $5 per cocktail, assuming you already have the basic barware. At a high-end bar, a New York Sour could cost anywhere from $12 to $20.

What is the Alcohol Content (ABV) of a New York Sour?

The Alcohol by Volume (ABV) of a New York Sour largely depends on the whiskey and wine you use. Generally speaking, the cocktail has an average ABV of 20–25%. Keep in mind that this is a rough estimate and can vary based on your specific ingredients.

New York Sour Decoded: Your Extended FAQs Explained

It seems like the more you delve into the world of the New York Sour, the more questions emerge. From the specifics of preparation time to recommended food pairings, this extended FAQ session aims to cover every aspect of this classic cocktail.

How Long Does It Take to Prepare a New York Sour?

The preparation time for a New York Sour is relatively quick, taking about 5 minutes. This includes the time for measuring ingredients, juicing the lemon, and setting up your barware.

What’s the Mixing Time for a New York Sour?

Once your ingredients and barware are set, the actual mixing time is quite brief—usually under 1 minute. This includes shaking the cocktail and adding the finishing touches like the red wine float and garnish.

How Many Servings Does the Recipe Make?

The standard New York Sour recipe makes one serving. It’s an individual cocktail designed to be enjoyed fresh. You can, of course, multiply the ingredients to make a larger batch, but it’s generally best served immediately after mixing.

What Type of Glass Should I Use?

A rocks glass, also known as a lowball or Old Fashioned glass, is the go-to for serving a New York Sour. Its wide brim allows you to appreciate the cocktail’s aroma, while the sturdy base is perfect for muddled ingredients and ice.

What is the Ideal Serving Temperature?

The New York Sour is best enjoyed cold, right after shaking and straining. Use fresh ice when serving to maintain the cocktail’s crisp temperature without diluting it quickly.

What Are the Exact Ingredients and Measurements?

For a classic New York Sour, you’ll need:

  • 60 ml (2 oz.) whiskey
  • 30 ml (1 oz.) fresh lemon juice
  • 15 ml (0.5 oz.) simple syrup
  • 15 ml (0.5 oz.) red wine

What are the Details on Garnishing?

A lemon twist or a small lemon wheel often serves as the garnish for a New York Sour. The lemon oils released add a pleasant aroma and a dash of color to the cocktail.

Should I Mix or Shake?

Shaking is the recommended method for a New York Sour. It helps to blend the ingredients thoroughly while aerating the cocktail for a frothier texture.

How Can I Elevate the Visual Presentation?

Adding the red wine float with the back of a spoon will create the distinct layering effect that makes the New York Sour visually stunning. Make sure to pour slowly to achieve this two-layer appearance.

What Are Some Recommended Food Pairings?

A New York Sour pairs wonderfully with hearty meals like steaks or BBQ dishes. The acidity of the lemon and the richness of the red wine cut through the fat, enhancing the dining experience.

Crafted by

Love Cocktails as we do?

Sign Up Now to get exclusive Cocktail Recipes straight to your inbox every day

Cosmopolitan vs Raspberry: Mix-Off